Author’s Note
I’m re-uploading the first part of The Ashen Oak as well. But here the highlights to the changes I
made to Part One:
- · Split into two shorter chapters
- · Added Prologue to foreshadow tree and raise stakes of world/story
- · Fixed sources of confusion about Oddy’s malapropisms
- · Omitted references to tree / replaced Pa’s bedtime story with London Ruins song
- · Introduced Edith’s cousin Anja (though her scene still needs some work)
- · Added scene where town finds out about the food shortage
- · Removed Uncle Jay and Edith fishing scene that set her on her quest
- · Added decision that Uncle Jay and Freja will go find her people for help
Regarding Chapter
3, I’d like to know if the pace is working. I didn’t want to rush Edith out of
the village too soon, so I gave her another scene with her cousin and one with
Oddy. I’m currently planning for Oddy to show up in the story again later. I
did introduce some hints that Oddy might have dogs in the house with him,
though I’m okay with that not being completely clear now. I purposely kept
their barking vague, as I assumed Edith would not have any knowledge of what a
dog is. I wanted to allow for a more sympathetic reason for Oddy to want so
much food, and I welcome to suggestions about whether I should further develop
this or not. Ultimately, I hoped Anja’s running off would feel like a smaller
and more personal quest for Edith to go on than journeying to save her world
right off the bat. Do you all feel that this works better and are there any
areas where I could make this feel more natural or believable?
Regarding
Chapter 4, I really would like some feedback on Edith’s time alone on the boat.
I tried to keep this section a bit shorter, as I feel that it’s pretty hard to
sustain the story when there is only one character. I thought the character of
Wernher (who will be one of the four main characters besides Edith, Anja, and
one yet to be introduced) helped with this a good bit. I wanted him to come off
as bit threatening, as readers and Edith don’t know his motives yet. My intent
is that he is not quite who he says he is and that his “family” are actually
the people manipulating the “tree” to cause the storms. Wernher is torn between
fulfilling his agreement to bring them slave workers and helping Edith. I’m
writing him to have feelings for Edith that she doesn’t (yet) share, especially
as that might open some conflict between him and the fourth main character. I’d
love some feedback on Wernher with this backstory in mind and whether you think
Edith’s travelling with him happens to quickly in the story. I didn’t really
want to have her wander off alone again, though it might be interesting to put
her in a situation where he has to show up again and save her. Finally, I’d
like some advice on whether I should put the story in the present tense instead
of the past. There were a few times during part two where I found myself
writing in the present because it felt a little bit more suspenseful. Thanks
for reading and I hope you enjoy!
--Chris
3. Pollywog
Hunter
“Why
not.” I wasn’t asking.
“Edith,”
Pa said, rubbing his eyes. “Are you really going to make me repeat ‘too
dangerous’ to you? Hasn’t that soaked into everyone yet?”
“But
Uncle Jay and Aunt Freja are both going.”
“Absolutely.”
Pa sat down at our table and threw up his hands. “And there’s nothing I can do
to change that. And that’s why you need to stay here to take care of Anja.” His
hand drifted down to a dried mushroom on the table, and then he pulled back. “These
are going to be tough times. Times that may be even worse for your cousin.”
I
studied Pa’s eyes, but they were fixed on the floor. “If you think something is
going to happen, all the more reason for me to go with them. Safety in
numbers.”
Pa
slammed his hand down on the table. “No more. I may have to take this from my
brother, but I will not take it from you.” Pa sighed. His hand drifted to
clutch his stomach. “Sorry. I shouldn’t have shouted at you. I just want the
best for you and Anja. For the whole village.” He held up a handful of the
dried mushrooms. “Come and eat. We’ll all need to be strong.”
My
stomach growled at the thought of the mushrooms. They crumbled into delicious dust
after just a few nibbles. “Can we at least see them off?”
Pa nodded. “We’ll
go as far as the river. There, we all can say our goodbyes.”
“What’s going to
happen to them, Pa? Do you think they’ll find the Northmen?”
“I think so.” Pa shifted
his jaw. “They’ll find them. Now how about we get to sleep? Your uncle and aunt
will be leaving at first light tomorrow.” He eased himself onto his bed.
I
pulled my box of treasures from under my bed and stared into my most prized
possession: my shard of mirror. Aunt Freja had found it in London Ruins and had
given it to me as a peace offering when she first came to our village and
married Uncle Jay. When I was little, I would look in the mirror as a game, but
now I rarely stole a glance. Pa said I every day I got older I looked like more
like Ma. As I looked, her green eyes stared back at me from behind the glassy
pane. “What are we to do?” I breathed, fogging the mirror up. The eyes grew
misty and I put the glass away.
*
“We
love you, Anja. We will be back soon.” Aunt Freja tucked the few stray strands
of Anja’s hair back under the hood of her raincoat. Uncle Jay was doing some
last checks on Rol’s old fishing boat, which we hadn’t used ever since the
rains got worse. Uncle Jay used to use it a lot to scavenge some floating
rubbish from the bogs, and sometimes to even snag a few fish. Right now, the
boat was just a sad shadow of its former self, its wooden hull bobbing up and
down at the water’s edge.
“Let
me come with you, Momma.” Anja held fast to her mother’s arm.
Aunt
Freja smiled and embraced her daughter. “Min
vakre jente, my beautiful girl. You must stay with your Uncle and your
cousin.”
“All
ready to go, Freja,” said Uncle Jay. “It’s time, little Anja.” He patted her on
the head.
“Bring
me back a gift.” Anja said, smiling and sniffling away her teetering tears.
“We
will. A gift for all of Rol. We promise.”
I
held on to Anja’s hand as her parents untethered the boat from the dock and
headed off through the flooded lowlands around the hills of Rol. Their boat
grew smaller and smaller until it finally disappeared in the dim gloom of the
morning fog.
“Good
luck,” Pa whispered. He stared into the haze for a good deal longer, and then
turned to us. “Well, that’s that. How about you girls come home for a little
bit of mushroom stew?”
“Can’t
we stay here, Uncle Evan?” Anja took hold of Pa’s hand with both of hers. “Just
for a little bit longer? What if Momma and Pappa forgot something? They might
come back and tell me to go get it for them.”
Pa
smiled down at her. “I think they remembered everything they needed.”
I
stared at him, shaking my head.
“But
if it would make you feel, better, you can stay here with Edith for a while.
Stay right here, and head back when your cousin says. Deal?”
Anja
nodded.
“Good.”
Pa turned to me and whispered into my ear. “Make sure to be home soon. There’s another
storm coming in. A bad one. I feel it in my knees.”
“Yes,
Pa.”
“See
you back home.” Pa hobbled back to the village, his walking stick poking
through the muddy ground.
Anja
and I stared out into the haze rising from the slimy pools of waterlogged
debris as tiny raindrops pitter-pattered on our raincoats. The Sun began
pushing through the mist in a pale glow, a glow that I rarely saw. I decided it
would be a good omen, no matter what Pa said about the coming rain.
“Ready
to go home?” I said after a while.
“No, Edith. I’m
going to follow my Momma and Pappa. Are you coming or not?”
“Don’t you think
we should go back to the village? We don’t exactly have a boat, you know.”
A little smile
crept across Anja’s face and she rolled her eyes. “Who needs a boat? You’ll be
going with Anja, pollywog hunter extraordinaire. I know these puddles like you
know your mushroom farm. Unless you’re scared of a little water.” With that,
Anja leaped across the murky pool to an unseen, shallow mound of mud.
“Anja, wait!”
“Better follow
quick, or you’ll be just a stick.” Anja giggled at her rhyme and hopped to
another shallow pad.
“Anja, seriously.
It’s not safe to go out there.”
“One, two, three. Jump.”
I leaned out over
the water. Grumbling, I jumped on the first shallow patch. The water splashed
up to my ankles and my boots sunk into the mud.
“Not so heavy,
Edith. Hop like a little frog through the bog.”
“Anja, stop it. Pa
would kill us if he saw this.”
“He’s not here.
Come on, we’ll be okay. I’ve got Northman blood in me. Momma always says we
were born on the water.” Anja grabbed hold of one of the old, rotten trunks of
a tree jutting out of the water and clambered up.
“Long way to go,
so don’t be slow.” She leapt to another tree trunk.
The glow of the Sun
started to fade. “Anja, I think the storm’s coming in. We need to get back.” Then
Anja began to fade as well, into the darkening mists. “Anja!”
“We have to
hurry,” she called back. “It’s a long way to London Ruins.”
“What? No. No,
you’re not going to London Ruins.”
“Why not?”
“It’s too
dangerous!” I sighed and hopped after her. Only, I misjudged where to jump and
fell up to my belly in the marshy water. By the time I made it back to shore,
Anja was gone.
“Soak it all.” I
muttered.
*
Steam
rose from some pipes at the top of Oddy’s hut, belching more of the pungent
stink into the air. It was the kind of stink that lingered and burned your nose
and the back of your throat. At least he didn’t have to worry about pests
around his place. I knocked at his front door, but there was no answer.
Frowning, I drummed again, harder.
There
was a string of loud, deep sounds, like some sort of hollow machinery.
“What
is it?” Oddy’s voice cried out.
“Od--”
I caught myself and began again. “Mr. Theodore. It’s me, Edith. Evan’s daughter.”
“Why
are you here? If your father thinks he can cheat me out of mine because he
sends a little girl, then he’s got another thing coming. So, why don’t you get
off my land before I have to come out there.”
“No,
Mr. Theodore. It’s not like that. My pa doesn’t know I’m here.”
Silence.
“I
came to ask for your help.”
“This
isn’t a food bank.”
“No,
I’m not here about food. My cousin is missing and I need to find her.”
“Not
my problem.”
“I
can pay. You wanted triple rations, right? And my father only gave you two.”
“Are
you threatening me?”
“No,
I’m offering to give you some of my share.”
A
pause and then Oddy unbolted his door and poked out his pinched face. He looked
about, probably to make sure this wasn’t some kind of trick of Pa’s. “What
makes you think I can help you?
“Anja
ran off to London Ruins. You’re the only one besides my Aunt who has been
through there.”
Oddy
tilted his head. His eyes seemed very distant, like the clouds beyond the
clouds. “I’ve been through the Ruins, yes.”
“How
did you get there?”
“A
boat, of course”
“Do
you still have it? Can take me there?”
His
mouth rippled like a stream, and then he burst out into a peal of laughter.
“Please, I can’t
get across the Floods.”
“You would have me
be your guide? Oh, my dear girl, there is no way that I am coming with you to
those Ruins.”
My heart sank. “Please, Mr. Theodore. It’s for
Anja. And triple rations.”
Oddy smirked and
shook his head—an unpleasant sight. “What do you know about London Ruins? Scary
tales to keep you in bed at night and from wandering off into the Floods?” He
leaned closer to my face, close enough that I could choke on the alcohol on his
breath. “Let my tell you, little girl, they’re all true, and even truer still.”
The loud sound
came again in three sharp bursts.
“I know, I know,
we’re all hungry!” He opened the door to his hut and gestured to me. “You want
to take my boat to find your friend? Well, maybe we can arrange that.”
I swallowed and
shuffled in the house. I had never been inside before and the place struck me
as strange as the man himself. Pipes ran along the floor and the walls, and papers
lay scattered along the ground, all arranged in shapes and patterns. Stinking
steam shrieked from a boiler at the far end of the house.
“Dry your feet on
the rug. Lose that dirty raincoat. I don’t want water around my house.” Oddy
glared at me until I was done. “Now then, allow me to show you my notes.” He
sprawled a set of thin sheets onto his table. “These are very old. Don’t touch
them.”
“Is this London
Ruins?”
“Mm. These are the
London Ruins I saw on my journey. Now I’m willing to tell you the best way to
find your friend, but you’re going to pay me your rations in advance. After all, who’s to
say you’ll even make it back?”
4. Trader
Oddy’s boat was
small, not much bigger than my bed. He gave me small piece of wood with purple
square of what he called plaster tied
to the end to paddle. There was a tiny crack in the bottom of the boat, where a
bit of water flooded in. I cupped my hand and scooped out the water from the
hole and the rain every few minutes.
He told me to head
out along the Floods, but to cut to the left as soon as I saw London Ruins.
There was a river he had taken to make it back to Rol during his wandering
days, but back then the river was just a newborn, a fledgling finger off the
great arm of the sea that ran through the Ruins. Now, the river was old and
angry because of the rains. It would not be so happy to meet me, and would pull
my boat out to sea.
Using the light of
the small peat-lamp Oddy had given me, I squinted through the dense fog for any
sign of Anja. I was following the path of most debris—the way that Anja would
have been able to cross. Every now and again my boat would slam into one of the
toothy trees that rose out of the murk, hidden by the fog. My heart would race
at each crash, but I wasn’t really scared. I told myself I was just afraid of
breaking the boat. Oddy had promised to keep this a secret, and provided I
didn’t damage anything, I would be back to Rol by nightfall with Pa none the
wiser. If Pa were to come to Oddy’s shack, Oddy was to tell him that he had
sent us out on a job to collect some ingredients for his compost
“Anja!” I called
out. But I was met with nothing, but the splashes of hungry rain, growing
heavier over the waters. I noticed the farther away from Rol I drifted, the
more the rain stung my eyes. It was getting hungrier.
I scooped handful
upon handful of water out of the boat and growled at the thought of Anja. It
was going to be a long, soaking trip.
*
I soon found
myself dealing with the problem of what to do when night fell. My lamp had long
since burned out and all attempts to relight it with debris from the water had
failed. In the depths of the storm, far away from the lamps of Rol, there was
nothing but darkness. I tried to squint through the rain, looking for some
shape or shadow that would indicate where I should go. I was quite certainly
lost.
“Anja!” I called
out once more, my throat hoarse. There was no point. I’d wait until tomorrow
and search some more. Silently, I cursed myself for not telling Pa. Any
scolding and punishment I’d get would be better than sitting out all alone in
Oddy’s boat in the middle of nowhere.
I tried not to
think about all the bad things that could have happened to Anja. She was the
pollywog hunter, I told myself, most fierce daughter of all the Northmen.
Nothing would happen to her. But then all her possible fates began to slip to
mind, pulling my thoughts down into the murk.
Shivering in the
rain, I hummed along to Pa’s “London Ruins” lullaby. But what seemed so
comforting back home in the warmth and light now grew eerie out here. At that
moment, my boat jerked to a stop. Reaching out into the darkness, I found I had
hit another of the skeletal tree trunks.
I pushed away from
the trunk, and then the boat hit another, a stray branch catching onto my
raincoat. I stood to try to free myself, and immediately realized my mistake.
The boat tipped back and forth then flipped. I plunged into the stinking water,
splashing about in the dark.
Before long, a
strong current caught me, and I felt myself being pulled away from the boat.
Frantic, I tried to grab hold of the tree, but it was so slick that my fingers
just grazed its rotting husk. I fought in vain to swim against the current and
kicked off my waterlogged boots to try to stay afloat.
I must have
strayed too far to the east. The river had me and there was nothing more I
could do. I craned my neck above the water and gasped for breath.
*
When
dawn finally came, I found myself drifting in the shallows of the river’s edge.
The withered London Ruins towered before me. They were skeletons of jagged
metal and crumbling stone. Skeletons of giants. I hadn’t seen anything that
tall before. Just looking up at the ancient buildings made the world spin. I
looked back to the water and staggered to shore.
Ahead
of me was a long clearing between the buildings, something that looked like the
street that ran down the center of Rol, only far bigger. Stony road hurt my
bare feet. I cursed as I wished I had not been stupid enough to flip Oddy’s
boat. I wouldn’t have lost my boots.
I
gasped and reached into my raincoat’s pocket. The mirror was still there and
undamaged. Thank the Sun, it had been spared. She had been spared.
“Guten Morgen, Fraülein!”
“What?” I jumped
at the strange voice accented in a way I hadn’t heard before.
A young man was
riding down the street toward me on some kind of wheeled contraption. It looked
like a giant version of the carts we used to move mulch from Oddy’s shack to
our house. But with this machine, the case was mostly flat and stacked with a
number of boxes draped in tarps. The boy sat at the back of the machine, moving
his feet up and down, making the wheels turn over the ground.
“Guten Morgen.” The young man smiled and
stepped off his contraption, extending his hand. He looked impossibly clean,
with his hair pulled back and his full face without any trace of grime. “It
means good morning where I’m from.
Now, Miss, how can I be of service?”
I held my ground.
“Who are you?”
“Apologies for my
rudeness, Miss. My name is Wernher. I happen to make my living as a trader
through the London area. Is there any way I can be of assistance, Miss…?”
“Miss will do.” I stared at him, wary of
any tricks. This Wernher wasn’t a Northman, his hair was darker and the shape
of his face was wrong. Nor was he like the people of Rol. He was wiry, but in a
healthy kind of way. His cheekbones didn’t show, and if Pa had said anything,
that meant he was no good. “I’m looking for something.”
“Ah! Well you’ve
come to the right place.” He patted the tarp-covered bundles on the front of
his cart. “Why don’t you take a look at my wares?”
“Your wares?”
“Yes. I’ve made it
a hobby of restoring whatever baubles I find around London. You might find just
what you’re looking for in my collection. Perhaps some dry clothing?”
“I think I’ll
pass.” Without turning my back on Wernher, I backed away toward one of the side
streets that wasn’t flooded or choked by debris.
He held up his
hands. “I don’t mean you any harm.”
“I’ll have to take
your word on that. Goodbye.”
The boy pedaled
his cart around the corner, following me. “I feel like we’ve gotten off on the
wrong leg. It looks like you’re going somewhere, and it’s not safe for a young
woman like yourself to wander through London alone. Allow me to give you a ride
to your destination.”
“No thank you, I
think I’ll manage.” My hand clutched the shard of mirror in my pocket.
“There’s no
charge. I see you may be a bit financially challenged at the moment, but I’d be
grateful to accept merely your company.”
My hand tightened
around the glass. “No.”
Wernher was taken
aback for a moment, his face turning. “Oh! I didn’t mean any disrespect. I beg
your pardon. I would never, I mean…it just looked like you could use some
help.” He reached into a bag piled on the cart. “Here, at least take something
to eat. You look famished.” He held out a round object.
At first, I
thought it was a rather large cap of a mushroom. It was a kind of light brown.
I merely stared at Wernher until he took the food back.
He tore the circle
apart in his hands and bit out of one half. “See? It’s good.” Swallowing, he
held out the other half.
I stared at him,
unmoving.
“I can set it on
the ground if you’d like. I’d rather not spoil it with mud, however.”
I stood facing
him, in this sort of standoff for many more moments. Then the smell of the food
drifted toward me and my stomach betrayed me. Shut up, I told it. But it was
not to be quieted. I hadn’t eaten in a day and was starved from all the rowing.
“Listen, Miss, we
can spend the day glaring at each other, but I don’t think that’s going to help
either of us. I’m going to set this down right here and then back up. You can
eat it if you want, or just leave it. Your choice.”
He did as he said,
and I waited for a few more moments, and then against my better judgment I
found the food in my hand. I took a careful nibble. It tasted earthy, vaguely
like mushrooms, but sweeter. The outside of the food was hard and crunchy but
the inside was soft.
“Guten Appetit!” Wernher said.
I felt strength
start to creep back to me. “That was good. Thank you. What is it called?
Wernher tilted his
head and chuckled. “Bread. We’d eat it usually with some butter or cheese, but
as you see it tastes perfectly good as it is. I have some more if you’d like.”
I narrowed my
eyes. “Why are you doing this?”
He smiled. “I just
want to help. Don’t be offended, but you look like you could use some. And
honestly, the more time I’m away from my family, the better.”
“Family?”
“Yes. They’ve got
their problems, but I still love them though.”
“I know the
feeling.”
“Are they traders
like you?”
Wernher shrugged.
“I suppose. I would take you to meet them, but they haven’t the best manners.”
He smiled. “So you’re looking for your family?”
Sighing, I decided
to tell him. “Yes. My cousin ran away from home and I’ve been looking for her.
I don’t suppose you’ve seen her? She’s a little golden-haired girl. She left to
go find her mother and father. They passed through the city yesterday by boat.”
“I haven’t seen
them. You’re the first person I’ve seen in a while.”
“Do you know the best place I could look?”
“Where were her
parents going?”
“To the north.” I
paused. “My aunt’s tribe lives on the far side of London Ruins.”
Wernher scratched
at his chin. “I haven’t heard of anyone living above London, but I’d be happy
to take you there. Maybe you’ll find that your cousin found her parents, and
they are all safe as sound.”
I grinned. “Safe as sound. I hope so. Do you have
any more food?”
“Certainly.” He
pulled another bread out of his bag.
“How long to the
other side of London Ruins?”
“My tricycle can
make it there in a little over a day if we leave now and I peddle hard.”
“Alright.” I felt
for the mirror shard in my pocket, just in case I’d need it. “Let’s go.”
Wernher held out
his hand to help me on his cart. I sat down on top of one of the boxes and he handed
me another tarp to cover myself.
“Thank you. I’m Edith
by the way.”
“It’s a pleasure
to meet you, Edith. Welcome to London.”
Together on Wernher’s strange contraption, we rolled our way through the foggy, rain-devoured bones of London Ruins.
Together on Wernher’s strange contraption, we rolled our way through the foggy, rain-devoured bones of London Ruins.
I think it’s a good decision not to rush Edith away from her home. I think the scenes in chapter three with Edith’s cousin and Oddy provide a stronger sense of Edith’s home and the troubles it is facing. I think adding dogs would be interesting, and it would explain a little more about Oddy’s situation. I liked your descriptions of his house, and Edith’s reaction to it. I also think having Anja run off is a strong incentive for Edith to leave Rol. I really like Anja’s character, and I think you can do a lot with her and her relationship with Edith. The scene with Edith alone in the boat is written well; it’s short enough that it doesn’t drag, but I liked seeing how Edith handles the situation and we get good descriptions of setting in the process. Wernher seems like a very intriguing character, and your description of him and his tricycle are well-written. I really like the tension between him and Edith. I don’t think him traveling with Edith happens too quickly, but I would like to see more of Edith’s reaction to seeing the London Ruins for the first time, before she meets Wernher. Maybe you can have her walk away from the river and see a few different images (buildings, landscape, etc) before meeting Wernher. As for switching the tense, I think it works as it is, but as I was reading I could see the possible benefits of switching into present. Doing so would definitely make the story more suspenseful, and since this is a journey/adventure story in which Edith will discover and experience a lot of new things and meet new people, I think present tense could help heighten the sense of both tension and excitement.
ReplyDeleteIn regards with Chapter 3, I believe you have accomplished what it is you were trying to do. Usually with "journey" stories, it is much more believable for someone to end up on the grand journey for more personal reasons rather than "I want to save the world" type mindset. Both Anja and Oddy have very strong personalities here. In regards with Oddy, I would encourage you to find a sympathetic motivation for him (or at least a motivation rather than being a crabby old sod) and I'm glad you mentioned in the author's notes that the sounds were dog's barking, otherwise I would have begun thinking of multiple different theories. All in all, Chapter 3 was well done.
ReplyDeleteI did have a couple of problems with chapter 4 though. The scenes with Edith in the boat I felt were fine. Sometimes you can add some good tension by making the protagonist have to brave the elements alone. However, I was a little confused about the setting. Given the overgrown tree trunks and shallow mud puddles, I thought Edith was traveling through some sort of bog, but later you state that it was a river, as it has currents. I know you said that Wernher's introduction to be a bit threatening, but I never felt that with reading him. I felt like there introduction was relatively harmless. However, I feel like that could be more effective, as it could complicate how Edith feels about him later on (with the romantic subplot). Overall, chapter 4 was good, but I felt like it needed a few more details. While I personally prefer Wernher to be more friendly and cordial, if you want him to seem more threatening, I would recommend he carry a weapon or act very suspicious towards Edith.
Enjoyed it!
Hey Chris! I agree with most of what has been said so far. I like having Edith start her journey because Anja has wandered off. Its a good reason for her to drop everything and go and it effectively gets rid of the adults and everyone else that might be an obstacle later on. However it felt like Edith was too relaxed about losing her younger cousin that she's supposed to be taking care of. I think we need to see her freak out a little more in order to make it more realistic. I would accentuate this specially on the scene where we see Anja hopping along the bog while Edith lags behind. This is a really good place to build suspense and rile up the reader. The scene with Oddy was interesting and it helped give him more depth. I really liked the descriptions of his house and the crummy boat he gives Edith. I like that Edith had to convince him to help her but I still think he should be a little more apprehensive about helping a young girl run away from home to find her lost cousin. I'm not saying he should not help her because he realizes that this will put her in danger, but he seems like the kind of person that wouldn't want to do anything out of selfishness and fear.
ReplyDeleteI liked how you introduced Wernher to the story. It seemed very natural and I like that you made him speak a different language because it adds complexity to the world. I was kind of confused at first when you described the tricycle that he rides. I hand't thought of a teenager or young man riding a tricycle so I thought he was riding a sort of go-cart or tractor until the word tricycle appeared later. I like the fact that its a tricycle because its so different and unique but I would mention it sooner and spend a little more time describing it. An easy way to do this is to mention that it has three wheels. I also felt like the conversation between Edith and Wernher needed to be a bit more awkward and tense. Keep in mind that Edith is traveling by herself away from home for the first time, she almost drowned, and she still hasn't found her cousin. I think all of those elements would make her a bit more apprehensive towards a stranger. I agree with Wes' comment of giving Wernher something so that Edith doesn't have much of a choice but to do as he says.
I really like your story and I'm so excited to see where Edith ends up next!
Chris, I thought your pacing worked well in these chapters! The only thing I'd dedicate more time to is when Anja leaves to follow her parents. I think there should be an even greater sense of panic from Edith, because, I mean, her cousin just left to HOP through the river without a boat allllll the way to London? That's huge and scary!! Also, I like the concept of Oddy having dogs and Edith not knowing what dogs are, but without your author's note I wouldn't have realized it was dog's making the sounds you described. I'm not sure how you could fix this, because it'd be hard to describe barking better than you already did - so maybe Edith catches a glimpse of one? I think chapter 4 is especially working well as far as pacing, action, and characterization. Just a couple things caught my attention: at one point you say Edith hopes to be home by nightfall, but then a couple paragraphs later she's already needing a lamp for nightfall? Also, I'm a little confused as the exact relation between Rol and the London Ruins. How far away are they? Is Rol across the English Channel - because mentioning rivers so much made me think she was travelling within inland, not out in open sea. Great tension and suspense overall!
ReplyDelete